首页 500强 活动 榜单 商业 科技 领导力 专题 品牌中心
杂志订阅

身败名裂的Theranos高管今何在?

Mahnoor Khan
2022-05-09

因为霍尔姆斯和公司总裁精心策划的旨在误导投资者、医生和患者的惊天阴谋,这家公司最终土崩瓦解。

文本设置
小号
默认
大号
Plus(0条)

血液检测初创公司Theranos曾经的估值一度高达90亿美元,目前已经不复存在。图片来源:MICHAEL SHORT—GETTY IMAGES

2014年,Theranos的创始人及首席执行官伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯成为全世界最年轻的白手起家的亿万富翁,登上了各家知名商业期刊的封面。

2022年,她再次登上了媒体头条,但这一次完全是由于错误的原因。Hulu的最新剧集《辍学生》(The Dropout),让霍尔姆斯及其与前任首席运营官桑尼·巴尔瓦尼的关系以及她的现状,再次引起了人们的关注。

本文介绍了霍尔姆斯故事的背景,以及她和巴尔瓦尼的现状和未来。

霍尔姆斯的崛起和倒下

霍尔姆斯幼年就梦想着成为亿万富翁。19岁时,她从斯坦福大学(Stanford University)肄业,创立了“革命性的”血液检测初创公司Theranos。霍尔姆斯承诺,Theranos进行血液检测不需要针头,称她“专有的”机器“Edison”只需要一个小针眼和一滴血,就能够得出对240多种疾病的检测结果,成本更低,而且速度更快。

霍尔姆斯的家族创建了美国第一家酵母公司,她是安然(Enron)前副总裁和美国国会助理的女儿。她显赫的背景帮助Theranos找到了一些美国最重量级的人物。

她任命美国前国务卿亨利·基辛格和美国疾控中心(CDC)前主任威廉·福奇等名人加入公司董事会,并从辉瑞(Pfizer)和西夫韦(Safeway)等行业巨头获得了合同。她甚至说服甲骨文(Oracle)创始人拉里·埃里森和药店行业巨头沃尔格林(Walgreens)等投资她的初创公司,在尚未披露其技术原理的情况下就融资超过7亿美元。

2015年,处在事业巅峰期的伊丽莎白,与美国前总统比尔·克林顿和阿里巴巴创始人马云共同出席座谈会。图片来源:Joshua LOTT—Getty Images

这种神秘感体现了公司的工作文化和伊丽莎白本人的作风。她雇佣保镖为自己开车,在办公室窗户上安装防弹玻璃,甚至禁止员工与其他部门的同事讨论项目。霍尔姆斯享受媒体的关注,她曾经参加过TED演讲(TED Talks),并与美国前总统比尔·克林顿和阿里巴巴创始人马云等人同台座谈。到2014年,Theranos在40家沃尔格林药店开设了检测中心,公司估值达到惊人的90亿美元。

尽管如此,有怀疑者开始对霍尔姆斯的说法提出质疑。

Theranos跌下神坛

2014年,Theranos的员工泰勒·舒尔茨曝光霍尔姆斯对检测过程中的质量控制检查漏洞视而不见。虽然受到霍尔姆斯的威胁,但泰勒依旧联系了纽约的公共健康实验室(Public Health Laboratory),指控Theranos篡改研究结果,并操纵实验室的能力验证。

到2015年,美国食品与药品管理局(FDA)对Theranos展开调查,发现其对患者开展的检测存在“严重错误”。例如,Theranos的性传播疾病检测号称准确率达到95%。然而监管人员发现,准确率只有65%至80%。

《华尔街日报》(Wall Street Journal)的记者约翰·卡雷鲁发表了一系列报道,揭露了霍尔姆斯的谎言和有缺陷的血液检测结果,霍尔姆斯的罪行终于被曝光。不久之后,沃尔格林起诉Theranos,指控其误导公司相信其技术的能力,要求赔偿1.4亿美元。2016年,美国证券交易委员会(SEC)以欺诈投资者和患者为由,突然指控霍尔姆斯及其前男友、Theranos首席运营官桑尼·巴尔瓦尼犯下11项重罪。2019年,Theranos彻底关闭。

罪行曝光

霍尔姆斯在2021年9月开始受审,在此期间检察官和证人曝光了她的欺诈行为。以下是审判过程中曝光的最令人震惊的部分事实:

1. 为了获得投资,霍尔姆斯声称全球最大的10家制药公司都验证了Theranos的结果。但事实并非如此。

2. 据称,霍尔姆斯在实验室结果上伪造了辉瑞的标识和信头,并出示给投资者,让投资者认为她与辉瑞达成了合作。

3. 为了隐瞒检测结果不准确的事实,Theranos用在传统机器上通过普通抽血得出的检测结果,替换Edison的检测报告;事实上,大部分检测均是在普通机器上完成。

4. 举报者证实,霍尔姆斯解雇了告诉她Edison无效的工程师。

5. Theranos的患者作证称,该医疗科技公司提供了不实的检测结果。患者布里塔尼·古尔德曾经被告知她出现了流产,但实际上胎儿非常健康。由于虚假的阳性检测结果,她更换了用药,可能对胎儿造成了伤害。

霍尔姆斯的辩护和桑尼·巴尔瓦尼

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯为自己辩护的主要理由是,她操控检测结果是本着进步的精神,她只是想让公司成功。她说:“失败不是罪。”

她还将大多数罪行推给了前男友桑尼·巴尔瓦尼,称他在两人的关系中控制和虐待她,影响了她的决策。

霍尔姆斯的律师出示了一份手写的便条,其中记录了她的日常安排和陈述,霍尔姆斯称巴尔瓦尼支配了她的一言一行。

便条最后几行写道:“我很少说话。即使讲话的时候也是言简意赅。我会马上表示异议。我经常把手插在口袋里,或者摆出姿势。”

巴尔瓦尼和律师否认了虐待指控,称这些指控是“淫秽的和具有煽动性的”,并坚称公司的最终决策者是霍尔姆斯而不是巴尔瓦尼。

但最近,巴尔瓦尼和霍尔姆斯之间的一系列短信往来被曝光,显示巴尔瓦尼拥有更多权力。

据美国全国广播公司(NBC)报道,巴尔瓦尼在发给霍尔姆斯的一条短信中写道:“我负责Theranos的一切事务。”

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯是否将锒铛入狱?

经过漫长的审判,在听取了近30名证人的证词后,法院判决霍尔姆斯对投资者的四项刑事欺诈指控成立,被判入狱20年,每项罪名罚款25万美元。陪审团宣布霍尔姆斯欺诈患者的罪名不成立。

由于这些罪名属于非暴力的白领犯罪,有法律专家认为,霍尔姆斯可能只需要服刑三年,而且将在较为高档的监狱内服刑,监狱的安保级别较低,还配备了许多设施,比如普拉提课、网球场和艺术课程等。她和丈夫比利·埃文斯的儿子最近出生,可能进一步缩短她的刑期。

白领辩护律师阿曼达·克雷默对美国国家公共广播电台(NPR)表示,霍尔姆斯案对可能试图欺诈的公司所有人具有震慑效果。她指出,如果霍尔姆斯免于服刑,将“令人感到非常震惊。”

巴尔瓦尼因为欺诈和虐待指控正在单独接受审判。克雷默称,巴尔瓦尼的案件会影响霍尔姆斯的判决,因此法院将判决日期定在了2022年9月。

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯的现状

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯曾经被誉为“下一个史蒂夫·乔布斯”,其资产净值一度高达45亿美元。据《福布斯》(Forbes)报道,霍尔姆斯目前已经失去了往日的荣光(和财富),现在的身家为0美元。霍尔姆斯以50万美元获得保释,目前与丈夫和儿子生活在位于硅谷的格林盖布尔斯(Green Gables)庄园,价值1.35亿美元。

桑尼·巴尔瓦尼今何在?

2022年3月,Theranos公司前总裁桑尼·巴尔瓦尼前往联邦法院受审。图片来源:David Paul Morris—Getty Images

巴尔瓦尼曾经任职于微软(Microsoft)和Lotus等公司,在20世纪90年代末的互联网泡沫期间成立了电子商务初创公司CommerceBid,赚取了大量财富。

互联网泡沫破灭之后,他选择继续求学,37岁时参加一个暑期项目前往中国,并在那里遇到了18岁的伊丽莎白。三年后的2005年,两人开始约会,巴尔瓦尼为霍尔姆斯提供了1300万美元个人贷款,帮助她运营Theranos。

2009年,巴尔瓦尼成为公司总裁兼首席运营官,与霍尔姆斯共同掌管Theranos,直到2016年两人分手后,巴尔瓦尼从公司辞职。作为Theranos的关键决策者,巴尔瓦尼被指控与霍尔姆斯犯有相同的罪名,并在2022年3月开始单独接受审判。

据媒体报道,为了筹集资金应对诉讼,他以约1600万美元的价格卖掉了曾经与霍尔姆斯共同拥有(后来被巴尔瓦尼买下)的豪宅。(财富中文网)

译者:刘进龙

审校:汪皓

2014年,Theranos的创始人及首席执行官伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯成为全世界最年轻的白手起家的亿万富翁,登上了各家知名商业期刊的封面。

2022年,她再次登上了媒体头条,但这一次完全是由于错误的原因。Hulu的最新剧集《辍学生》(The Dropout),让霍尔姆斯及其与前任首席运营官桑尼·巴尔瓦尼的关系以及她的现状,再次引起了人们的关注。

本文介绍了霍尔姆斯故事的背景,以及她和巴尔瓦尼的现状和未来。

霍尔姆斯的崛起和倒下

霍尔姆斯幼年就梦想着成为亿万富翁。19岁时,她从斯坦福大学(Stanford University)肄业,创立了“革命性的”血液检测初创公司Theranos。霍尔姆斯承诺,Theranos进行血液检测不需要针头,称她“专有的”机器“Edison”只需要一个小针眼和一滴血,就能够得出对240多种疾病的检测结果,成本更低,而且速度更快。

霍尔姆斯的家族创建了美国第一家酵母公司,她是安然(Enron)前副总裁和美国国会助理的女儿。她显赫的背景帮助Theranos找到了一些美国最重量级的人物。

她任命美国前国务卿亨利·基辛格和美国疾控中心(CDC)前主任威廉·福奇等名人加入公司董事会,并从辉瑞(Pfizer)和西夫韦(Safeway)等行业巨头获得了合同。她甚至说服甲骨文(Oracle)创始人拉里·埃里森和药店行业巨头沃尔格林(Walgreens)等投资她的初创公司,在尚未披露其技术原理的情况下就融资超过7亿美元。

这种神秘感体现了公司的工作文化和伊丽莎白本人的作风。她雇佣保镖为自己开车,在办公室窗户上安装防弹玻璃,甚至禁止员工与其他部门的同事讨论项目。霍尔姆斯享受媒体的关注,她曾经参加过TED演讲(TED Talks),并与美国前总统比尔·克林顿和阿里巴巴创始人马云等人同台座谈。到2014年,Theranos在40家沃尔格林药店开设了检测中心,公司估值达到惊人的90亿美元。

尽管如此,有怀疑者开始对霍尔姆斯的说法提出质疑。

Theranos跌下神坛

2014年,Theranos的员工泰勒·舒尔茨曝光霍尔姆斯对检测过程中的质量控制检查漏洞视而不见。虽然受到霍尔姆斯的威胁,但泰勒依旧联系了纽约的公共健康实验室(Public Health Laboratory),指控Theranos篡改研究结果,并操纵实验室的能力验证。

到2015年,美国食品与药品管理局(FDA)对Theranos展开调查,发现其对患者开展的检测存在“严重错误”。例如,Theranos的性传播疾病检测号称准确率达到95%。然而监管人员发现,准确率只有65%至80%。

《华尔街日报》(Wall Street Journal)的记者约翰·卡雷鲁发表了一系列报道,揭露了霍尔姆斯的谎言和有缺陷的血液检测结果,霍尔姆斯的罪行终于被曝光。不久之后,沃尔格林起诉Theranos,指控其误导公司相信其技术的能力,要求赔偿1.4亿美元。2016年,美国证券交易委员会(SEC)以欺诈投资者和患者为由,突然指控霍尔姆斯及其前男友、Theranos首席运营官桑尼·巴尔瓦尼犯下11项重罪。2019年,Theranos彻底关闭。

罪行曝光

霍尔姆斯在2021年9月开始受审,在此期间检察官和证人曝光了她的欺诈行为。以下是审判过程中曝光的最令人震惊的部分事实:

1. 为了获得投资,霍尔姆斯声称全球最大的10家制药公司都验证了Theranos的结果。但事实并非如此。

2. 据称,霍尔姆斯在实验室结果上伪造了辉瑞的标识和信头,并出示给投资者,让投资者认为她与辉瑞达成了合作。

3. 为了隐瞒检测结果不准确的事实,Theranos用在传统机器上通过普通抽血得出的检测结果,替换Edison的检测报告;事实上,大部分检测均是在普通机器上完成。

4. 举报者证实,霍尔姆斯解雇了告诉她Edison无效的工程师。

5. Theranos的患者作证称,该医疗科技公司提供了不实的检测结果。患者布里塔尼·古尔德曾经被告知她出现了流产,但实际上胎儿非常健康。由于虚假的阳性检测结果,她更换了用药,可能对胎儿造成了伤害。

霍尔姆斯的辩护和桑尼·巴尔瓦尼

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯为自己辩护的主要理由是,她操控检测结果是本着进步的精神,她只是想让公司成功。她说:“失败不是罪。”

她还将大多数罪行推给了前男友桑尼·巴尔瓦尼,称他在两人的关系中控制和虐待她,影响了她的决策。

霍尔姆斯的律师出示了一份手写的便条,其中记录了她的日常安排和陈述,霍尔姆斯称巴尔瓦尼支配了她的一言一行。

便条最后几行写道:“我很少说话。即使讲话的时候也是言简意赅。我会马上表示异议。我经常把手插在口袋里,或者摆出姿势。”

巴尔瓦尼和律师否认了虐待指控,称这些指控是“淫秽的和具有煽动性的”,并坚称公司的最终决策者是霍尔姆斯而不是巴尔瓦尼。

但最近,巴尔瓦尼和霍尔姆斯之间的一系列短信往来被曝光,显示巴尔瓦尼拥有更多权力。

据美国全国广播公司(NBC)报道,巴尔瓦尼在发给霍尔姆斯的一条短信中写道:“我负责Theranos的一切事务。”

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯是否将锒铛入狱?

经过漫长的审判,在听取了近30名证人的证词后,法院判决霍尔姆斯对投资者的四项刑事欺诈指控成立,被判入狱20年,每项罪名罚款25万美元。陪审团宣布霍尔姆斯欺诈患者的罪名不成立。

由于这些罪名属于非暴力的白领犯罪,有法律专家认为,霍尔姆斯可能只需要服刑三年,而且将在较为高档的监狱内服刑,监狱的安保级别较低,还配备了许多设施,比如普拉提课、网球场和艺术课程等。她和丈夫比利·埃文斯的儿子最近出生,可能进一步缩短她的刑期。

白领辩护律师阿曼达·克雷默对美国国家公共广播电台(NPR)表示,霍尔姆斯案对可能试图欺诈的公司所有人具有震慑效果。她指出,如果霍尔姆斯免于服刑,将“令人感到非常震惊。”

巴尔瓦尼因为欺诈和虐待指控正在单独接受审判。克雷默称,巴尔瓦尼的案件会影响霍尔姆斯的判决,因此法院将判决日期定在了2022年9月。

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯的现状

伊丽莎白·霍尔姆斯曾经被誉为“下一个史蒂夫·乔布斯”,其资产净值一度高达45亿美元。据《福布斯》(Forbes)报道,霍尔姆斯目前已经失去了往日的荣光(和财富),现在的身家为0美元。霍尔姆斯以50万美元获得保释,目前与丈夫和儿子生活在位于硅谷的格林盖布尔斯(Green Gables)庄园,价值1.35亿美元。

桑尼·巴尔瓦尼今何在?

巴尔瓦尼曾经任职于微软(Microsoft)和Lotus等公司,在20世纪90年代末的互联网泡沫期间成立了电子商务初创公司CommerceBid,赚取了大量财富。

互联网泡沫破灭之后,他选择继续求学,37岁时参加一个暑期项目前往中国,并在那里遇到了18岁的伊丽莎白。三年后的2005年,两人开始约会,巴尔瓦尼为霍尔姆斯提供了1300万美元个人贷款,帮助她运营Theranos。

2009年,巴尔瓦尼成为公司总裁兼首席运营官,与霍尔姆斯共同掌管Theranos,直到2016年两人分手后,巴尔瓦尼从公司辞职。作为Theranos的关键决策者,巴尔瓦尼被指控与霍尔姆斯犯有相同的罪名,并在2022年3月开始单独接受审判。

据媒体报道,为了筹集资金应对诉讼,他以约1600万美元的价格卖掉了曾经与霍尔姆斯共同拥有(后来被巴尔瓦尼买下)的豪宅。(财富中文网)

译者:刘进龙

审校:汪皓

In 2014, Theranos founder and CEO Elizabeth Holmes was dominating the front covers of renowned business magazines for being the youngest self-made billionaire in the world.

In 2022, she’s making headlines again ––but for all the wrong reasons. A recent Hulu series, The Dropout, has led to more interest in Holmes, her relationship with former COO Sunny Balwani, and where she is today.

Here's the background on Holmes' story, what she and Balwani are doing today, and what the future could hold.

Holmes' story and fall from grace

Holmes had a childhood dream of becoming a billionaire. At 19, she dropped out of Stanford to work on her "revolutionary" blood-testing startup called Theranos. With Theranos, Holmes promised to eliminate needles from the blood testing process, claiming that her "proprietary" machine called the "Edison" could deliver cheaper and faster results for over 240 diseases with a single pin-prick and a drop of blood.

Holmes was a descendant of the family that founded America’s first yeast company and was also the daughter of a former Enron VP and congressional aide. Her pedigreed background helped link Theranos with some of the biggest names in America.

She appointed luminaries like former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and ex-director of CDC William Foege to her board of directors and landed contracts with industry giants like Pfizer and Safeway. She even convinced high-profilers like Oracle founder Larry Ellison and pharmacy leader Walgreens to invest in her startup, raising over $700 million without ever disclosing how her technology worked.

This secrecy reflected the company’s work culture and Elizabeth herself, who hired bodyguards to drive her around, installed bulletproof glass in her office windows, and forbade employees from discussing projects with workers in other departments. Holmes enjoyed the media spotlight, speaking at TED Talks and panels with Bill Clinton and Jack Ma. By 2014, Theranos had testing centers in 40 Walgreens stores and was valued at a whopping $9 billion.

But while all this was happening, skeptics started questioning Holmes’ claims.

A downward spiral for Theranos

In 2014, Theranos employee Tyler Schultz called out Holmes for ignoring failed quality control checks in the testing process. Despite receiving threats from Holmes, Tyler contacted the Public Health Laboratory in New York, alleging that Theranos was doctoring research and manipulating its proficiency testing.

By 2015, the FDA was investigating Theranos, finding “major inaccuracies” in the tests it was performing on patients. For example, a Theranos STD test claimed it was accurate 95% of the time. But regulators found the results to be accurate only 65% to 80% of the time.

Holmes’ misdeeds caught public attention when WSJ reporter John Carreyrou published a series of reports exposing her lies and flawed blood test results. Soon after, Walgreens sued Theranos for $140 million dollars for misleading them about the capabilities of the technology. In 2016, the SEC slapped Holmes and her ex-boyfriend and Theranos COO Sunny Balwani with 11 felony counts for fraud against investors and patients. Theranos completely shut down by 2019.

Holmes exposed

Holmes’ trial began in September 2021 and prosecutors and witnesses exposed her as a fraud. Here are some of the most shocking revelations of the trial:

1. To get investor funding, Holmes claimed that the world’s 10 largest pharmaceutical companies had validated Theranos’ results. They had not.

2. Holmes allegedly forged Pfizer’s logo and letterhead on the lab results she showed to investors to make them think she had contracts with Pfizer.

3. Theranos hid its inaccuracies by substituting Edison’s reports with results from regular blood draws done on traditional machines; in fact, most tests were run on regular machines.

4. Whistleblowers testified to Holmes firing engineers who told her the Edison didn’t work.

5. Ex-Theranos patients testified against the health tech company for providing faulty test results. One such patient was Brittany Gould, who was told that she was having a miscarriage when, in fact, she had a healthy pregnancy. Because of the false positive, she changed the medication she was taking, which could have harmed the fetus.

Holmes’ defense & Sunny Balwani

Elizabeth Holmes’ central defense was that her manipulations were in the spirit of progress and that she was simply trying to make the company succeed. “Coming up short is not a crime,” she said.

She also blamed her ex-partner Sunny Balwani for most of the wrongdoings, claiming that he controlled and abused her throughout their relationship, which hindered her decision-making.

Holmes’ lawyer presented a handwritten note that outlined her daily schedule and affirmations which, according to Holmes, Balwani dictated along with how she should act and speak.

“I speak rarely. When I do—CRISP and CONCISE. I call bullshit immediately. My hands are always in my pockets or gesturing,” the last few lines of the note read.

Balwani and his lawyers have denied the abuse claims, calling them “salacious and inflammatory” and remain firm that Holmes was the final decision-maker of the company, not Balwani.

But recently, a series of text exchanges between Balwani and Holmes came forward, suggesting Balwani had more power than he admits.

“I am responsible for everything at Theranos,” Balwani wrote in a text to Holmes, as reported by NBC.

Will Elizabeth Holmes go to prison?

After a lengthy trial and almost 30 witnesses, the court found Holmes guilty of four counts of criminal fraud against investors with 20 years in prison and a $250,000 fine for each of her convictions. The jury acquitted Holmes of charges of fraud against patients.

Because the conviction was for a non-violent, white-collar crime, legal experts think it’s likely that Holmes will only spend three years behind bars, and that too in a premium prison with low security and plenty of facilities like pilates classes, tennis courts, and arts programs. The recent birth of her baby boy with husband Billy Evans could further reduce her sentence.

White-collar defense lawyer Amanda Kramer told NPR that Holmes’ case is a deterrent for business owners who may intend to commit fraud. She said it would be "utterly shocking" if Holmes dodged imprisonment.

Balwani is going through a separate trial for fraud along with the abuse allegations. According to Kramer, Balwani’s case affects Holmes’ sentence, which is why the court has set her sentencing date in September 2022.

Where is Elizabeth Holmes right now?

Once touted “the next Steve Jobs” with a net worth of $4.5 billion, Elizabeth Holmes has fallen from grace (and money) and is now worth $0, according to Forbes. Currently out on a $500,000 bail bond, Holmes is living it up in her $135 million Green Gables estate in Silicon Valley with her husband and son.

Where is Sunny Balwani today?

After working at companies like Microsoft and Lotus, Sunny made his riches after founding his e-commerce startup CommerceBid at the peak of the dot-com bubble in the late 90s.

After the industry burst, he pursued further studies and, at 37, went to China as part of a summer program where he met 18-year-old Elizabeth. After 3 years in 2005, the two started dating and Sunny gave Holmes a $13 million personal loan to help fund Theranos.

In 2009, Sunny became the president and COO, reigning the Theranos C-suite with Holmes until the pair split in 2016 and he quit the company. As a key decision-maker in Theranos, Sunny has been charged with the same counts as Holmes and is going through a separate trial that began in March 2022.

It has been reported that he just sold the luxury home he and Holmes co-owned (later bought out by Balwani) for almost $16 million as he plows money for his ongoing litigation.

财富中文网所刊载内容之知识产权为财富媒体知识产权有限公司及/或相关权利人专属所有或持有。未经许可,禁止进行转载、摘编、复制及建立镜像等任何使用。
0条Plus
精彩评论
评论

撰写或查看更多评论

请打开财富Plus APP

前往打开