全球第二大、同时也是增长最快的加密货币交易所——FTX在被竞争对手币安(Binance)收购的过程中一夜崩溃,消息传来,整个加密货币世界都为之一惊。
FTX并非首个突然崩塌的大型加密货币机构,与之类似的还有Celsius和Voyager,二者均在今年春天申请破产保护。在退场过程中,试图维持公司运营的管理层还把手伸进了客户账户。随着FTX破产倒闭的全部影响逐渐清晰,市场开始担忧,将通证(token)存放在交易所或经纪商处是否足够安全。
FTX崩盘的重大影响
对于那些并未持续关注加密货币行业动向的人士而言,无论从哪个角度来看,FTX的崩溃都是一件大事。
贵为全球第二大加密货币交易所,FTX及其首席执行官萨姆·班克曼-弗里德(绰号SBF)都是加密货币世界里冉冉升起的新星。就在今年8月,SBF还登上了《财富》杂志的封面,而按照乔希·弗雷泽的说法,甚至在此之前,SBF就已经是备受尊敬的知名人士了。乔希·弗雷泽是Origin Protocol公司的联合创始人,该公司推出了可以获得收益的稳定币——Origin Dollar和NFT(非同质化代币)平台——Origin Story。
“这件事情绝对会产生重大影响。”弗雷泽在一次接受采访时说,“SBF在业内非常高调,赞助过体育场馆,登上过杂志封面,还曾经前往华盛顿与监管机构交涉,要求加大对加密货币的监管力度,为了出名,他付出了很多努力,而且一直非常值得信赖。很多人都对他推崇备至,认为他很靠谱。”
但FTX最终似乎并未做到“名副其实”,也未能恪守对客户的承诺(比如不对外出借客户入金、确保客户存在FTX中的资产安全),弗雷泽表示。他还补充道:“很明显,事实并不是FTX所承诺的那样,资产存放在他们那里并不安全。因此,FTX崩盘事件绝对会产生重大影响,遗憾的是,很多无辜人士正在因为FTX的不负责任而受到伤害”。
虽然FTX的崩塌会造成多大损失还有待观察,但加密货币投资者依然能够从这个案例中吸取一些教训,其中最重要的是,将加密货币存放在交易所或经纪商处(尤其是在市场动荡或衰退的时期)并非最安全的做法。
是否应将加密货币存放在经纪商和交易所处?
我们必须对一般性加密货币投资(据专家介绍,如果可以遵守一些重要原则,此类投资目前就依然安全)与将加密货币存放在经纪商或交易所处的行为进行区分。
经纪商和交易所往往不够透明,而且交给他们等同于允许他人保管你的资产,并且相信他们能够做到“履职尽责”。
1. 无钥即无币,币钥为一体
“无钥即无币,币钥为一体。”这是加密货币行业的一句名言,也是这个行业的一个黄金法则,其本质上可以归结为一个事实,即:如果你把自己的加密货币交给其他人保管,那就相当于你放弃了对这些加密货币的控制权。
Castle Funds的总裁兼首席信息官彼得·埃伯利称:“把加密货币放在交易所(无论是中心化交易所还是去中心化交易所)就等同于放弃了控制权,选择相信他们的承诺,相信他们会保管好你的比特币(Bitcoin)。”Castle Funds是一家投资公司,自2017年以来一直在管理加密货币投资基金,对比特币和其他数字货币进行投资。
FTX事件表明,加密货币交易所透明不足的问题依然存在,这给管理不当行为的出现留下了空间,在此背景之下,自然是小心为妙。“在股票市场上进行交易时,我们能够放心地把股票交给托管人,因为他们受到的监管更为严密,还会受到审计。而加密货币交易所则是‘暗箱操作’,无法了解其中情况。”埃伯利补充道,“就在今天,又有几家交易所发布公告,表示自己将不得不提高透明度。”
弗雷泽也给出了类似的建议,他指出,无论市场整体情况如何,把加密货币存在交易所都不是明智之举。
弗雷泽称:“FDX并非首个崩盘的交易所。加密货币的全部意义就在于,我们不必再将信任寄托在他人身上。加密货币的出现就是为了解决这个问题,帮助我们摆脱那些不知道拿我们的钱做什么的不透明体系。”
2. 保管好自己的资产
正如前文所说,我们认为与其将加密货币存放在交易所或经纪商处,还不如自己保管,这样要安全得多。所谓自己保管是指将其存在一个类似U盘的硬件钱包或者在线软件钱包中。无论哪种方式,加密货币的控制权都依然在你手中,并且可以通过私钥加密对其进行保护。
弗雷泽解释道:“私钥加密使用的技术与确保我们能够安全访问网站、在网上输入信用卡信息的技术相同。这些密钥可以确保你的数字资产安全无虞”。
埃伯利表示,如果选择硬件钱包(例如Ledger钱包),那么只有转账时,你的加密货币才会出现在互联网上。其余时间,你能够把存有加密货币的硬件钱包放在保险箱或保险柜里。
3. 选择有专业人员管理的账户进行投资
对于高净值加密货币投资者来说,通过有专业人员管理的账户进行投资,也是一种保障资产安全的手段。这就是埃伯利的公司Castle Funds正在做的事情。该公司专注于与那些经过资质认证的高净值投资者合作,在处理加密货币投资时,该公司会使用离线托管工具存放客户资产。
埃伯利表示:“绝大多数时间,我们的通证都以离线方式保管,所以可以规避风险(比如交易所的风险)。把通证存放在交易所的原因不是懒惰,就是不知道如何将加密货币存入自己的钱包。”
如果你才接触加密货币投资,那么一定就要找个有经验的人带你了解如何将加密货币存入自己的钱包。
弗雷泽指出,就加密货币投资整体来说,目前仍然安全,这是底线。但交易所和经纪商不够透明的问题依然存在。
“不要把在这些交易所的问题与加密货币本身混为一谈。”弗雷泽说,“一定不要把钱放在交易所,尽快提走。不过事实一直如此。如果你不放心自己保管,那么就可以考虑将其放在像Coinbase这样受监管的平台,Coinbase是一个透明平台,并且会公布自己的加密货币储备,不会搞些见不得人的把戏,用户能够放心地把加密货币放在那里。”(财富中文网)
编者注:本文包含的建议、意见或排名出自Fortune Recommends™编辑团队。相关内容未经任何合作伙伴或其他第三方审查,也未得到任何合作伙伴或其他第三方认可。
译者:梁宇
审校:夏林
全球第二大、同时也是增长最快的加密货币交易所——FTX在被竞争对手币安(Binance)收购的过程中一夜崩溃,消息传来,整个加密货币世界都为之一惊。
FTX并非首个突然崩塌的大型加密货币机构,与之类似的还有Celsius和Voyager,二者均在今年春天申请破产保护。在退场过程中,试图维持公司运营的管理层还把手伸进了客户账户。随着FTX破产倒闭的全部影响逐渐清晰,市场开始担忧,将通证(token)存放在交易所或经纪商处是否足够安全。
FTX崩盘的重大影响
对于那些并未持续关注加密货币行业动向的人士而言,无论从哪个角度来看,FTX的崩溃都是一件大事。
贵为全球第二大加密货币交易所,FTX及其首席执行官萨姆·班克曼-弗里德(绰号SBF)都是加密货币世界里冉冉升起的新星。就在今年8月,SBF还登上了《财富》杂志的封面,而按照乔希·弗雷泽的说法,甚至在此之前,SBF就已经是备受尊敬的知名人士了。乔希·弗雷泽是Origin Protocol公司的联合创始人,该公司推出了可以获得收益的稳定币——Origin Dollar和NFT(非同质化代币)平台——Origin Story。
“这件事情绝对会产生重大影响。”弗雷泽在一次接受采访时说,“SBF在业内非常高调,赞助过体育场馆,登上过杂志封面,还曾经前往华盛顿与监管机构交涉,要求加大对加密货币的监管力度,为了出名,他付出了很多努力,而且一直非常值得信赖。很多人都对他推崇备至,认为他很靠谱。”
但FTX最终似乎并未做到“名副其实”,也未能恪守对客户的承诺(比如不对外出借客户入金、确保客户存在FTX中的资产安全),弗雷泽表示。他还补充道:“很明显,事实并不是FTX所承诺的那样,资产存放在他们那里并不安全。因此,FTX崩盘事件绝对会产生重大影响,遗憾的是,很多无辜人士正在因为FTX的不负责任而受到伤害”。
虽然FTX的崩塌会造成多大损失还有待观察,但加密货币投资者依然能够从这个案例中吸取一些教训,其中最重要的是,将加密货币存放在交易所或经纪商处(尤其是在市场动荡或衰退的时期)并非最安全的做法。
是否应将加密货币存放在经纪商和交易所处?
我们必须对一般性加密货币投资(据专家介绍,如果可以遵守一些重要原则,此类投资目前就依然安全)与将加密货币存放在经纪商或交易所处的行为进行区分。
经纪商和交易所往往不够透明,而且交给他们等同于允许他人保管你的资产,并且相信他们能够做到“履职尽责”。
1. 无钥即无币,币钥为一体
“无钥即无币,币钥为一体。”这是加密货币行业的一句名言,也是这个行业的一个黄金法则,其本质上可以归结为一个事实,即:如果你把自己的加密货币交给其他人保管,那就相当于你放弃了对这些加密货币的控制权。
Castle Funds的总裁兼首席信息官彼得·埃伯利称:“把加密货币放在交易所(无论是中心化交易所还是去中心化交易所)就等同于放弃了控制权,选择相信他们的承诺,相信他们会保管好你的比特币(Bitcoin)。”Castle Funds是一家投资公司,自2017年以来一直在管理加密货币投资基金,对比特币和其他数字货币进行投资。
FTX事件表明,加密货币交易所透明不足的问题依然存在,这给管理不当行为的出现留下了空间,在此背景之下,自然是小心为妙。“在股票市场上进行交易时,我们能够放心地把股票交给托管人,因为他们受到的监管更为严密,还会受到审计。而加密货币交易所则是‘暗箱操作’,无法了解其中情况。”埃伯利补充道,“就在今天,又有几家交易所发布公告,表示自己将不得不提高透明度。”
弗雷泽也给出了类似的建议,他指出,无论市场整体情况如何,把加密货币存在交易所都不是明智之举。
弗雷泽称:“FDX并非首个崩盘的交易所。加密货币的全部意义就在于,我们不必再将信任寄托在他人身上。加密货币的出现就是为了解决这个问题,帮助我们摆脱那些不知道拿我们的钱做什么的不透明体系。”
2. 保管好自己的资产
正如前文所说,我们认为与其将加密货币存放在交易所或经纪商处,还不如自己保管,这样要安全得多。所谓自己保管是指将其存在一个类似U盘的硬件钱包或者在线软件钱包中。无论哪种方式,加密货币的控制权都依然在你手中,并且可以通过私钥加密对其进行保护。
弗雷泽解释道:“私钥加密使用的技术与确保我们能够安全访问网站、在网上输入信用卡信息的技术相同。这些密钥可以确保你的数字资产安全无虞”。
埃伯利表示,如果选择硬件钱包(例如Ledger钱包),那么只有转账时,你的加密货币才会出现在互联网上。其余时间,你能够把存有加密货币的硬件钱包放在保险箱或保险柜里。
3. 选择有专业人员管理的账户进行投资
对于高净值加密货币投资者来说,通过有专业人员管理的账户进行投资,也是一种保障资产安全的手段。这就是埃伯利的公司Castle Funds正在做的事情。该公司专注于与那些经过资质认证的高净值投资者合作,在处理加密货币投资时,该公司会使用离线托管工具存放客户资产。
埃伯利表示:“绝大多数时间,我们的通证都以离线方式保管,所以可以规避风险(比如交易所的风险)。把通证存放在交易所的原因不是懒惰,就是不知道如何将加密货币存入自己的钱包。”
如果你才接触加密货币投资,那么一定就要找个有经验的人带你了解如何将加密货币存入自己的钱包。
弗雷泽指出,就加密货币投资整体来说,目前仍然安全,这是底线。但交易所和经纪商不够透明的问题依然存在。
“不要把在这些交易所的问题与加密货币本身混为一谈。”弗雷泽说,“一定不要把钱放在交易所,尽快提走。不过事实一直如此。如果你不放心自己保管,那么就可以考虑将其放在像Coinbase这样受监管的平台,Coinbase是一个透明平台,并且会公布自己的加密货币储备,不会搞些见不得人的把戏,用户能够放心地把加密货币放在那里。”(财富中文网)
编者注:本文包含的建议、意见或排名出自Fortune Recommends™编辑团队。相关内容未经任何合作伙伴或其他第三方审查,也未得到任何合作伙伴或其他第三方认可。
译者:梁宇
审校:夏林
The crypto world has been reeling today amid news that FTX, the second-largest and fastest-growing crypto exchange, essentially collapsed overnight amid a takeover by rival Binance.
This is not the first time that a large crypto firm has folded abruptly. Celsius and Voyager provide two similar examples—both went under this past spring. And on their way out, dipped into customer accounts to try and stay afloat. As the full ramifications of the FTX insolvency and collapse become clear, it raises questions about just how safe it is to keep tokens in exchanges or with brokerages.
The significance the FTX collapse
For those who don’t follow every twist and turn of the crypto industry, the collapse of FTX is a big deal by any measure.
As the second-largest crypto exchange, FTX and its CEO Sam Bankman-Fried, who goes by SBF, were rising stars in the crypto world. Just this past August, SBF appeared on the cover of Fortune, and even prior to that he was a very public and well-respected figure, says Josh Fraser, co-founder of Origin Protocol, a company that created Origin Dollar, a yield-bearing stable coin, and Origin Story, an NFT platform.
“This is absolutely massive,” Fraser said during an interview. “SBF has been very visible in the industry—from sponsoring stadiums and appearing on the cover of magazines to being in Washington D.C. talking to regulators and calling for more regulations of crypto—he’s been really working to make a name for himself and has been a very trusted person. A lot of people respected him and viewed him as a good actor.”
In the end however, it seems FTX was not all that it appeared and had not been keeping its promises to its customers, says Fraser. This includes promises about not lending out customer deposits and that customer assets were safe with FTX. “Clearly that was not the case. Assets were not safe. So this is absolutely huge and unfortunately a lot of innocent people are getting hurt by this,” Fraser added.
While it remains to be seen just how much damage will be done by FTX’s implosion, there are some lessons crypto investors can learn from this case. Chief among them—keeping coins in crypto exchanges or brokerages, particularly amid volatility or downturns, is not the safest move.
Should you keep crypto in brokerages and exchanges?
It’s important to make a distinction between investing in crypto generally—which experts say still remains safe when you follow a few key best practices—and keeping your coins in brokerages or exchanges such as FTX.
There is often a lack of transparency with brokerages and exchanges that can be problematic, you’re also allowing someone else to hold your assets, and trusting that they will do so responsibly.
1. Not your keys, not your coins
There’s a well-known expression or golden rule in the crypto industry—“Not your keys, not your coins.” And it essentially boils down to the fact that when you turn your coins over to someone else to hold and keep secure, you’re abdicating control over them.
“When you leave your crypto on an exchange, whether it’s centralized or decentralized, you have given up control. You’re taking their promise that your bitcoins are actually there,” says Peter Eberle, president and chief information officer for Castle Funds, an investment firm that has been managing funds invested in Bitcoin and other digital currencies since 2017.
This is concerning because as the FTX case makes clear, there continues to be a lack of transparency among exchanges, which leaves opportunity for mismanagement. “On the stock market, you leave your stocks with a custodian, and it’s safe because they are more regulated, and they are audited. These exchanges work in this dark hole where you can’t see into it,” continues Eberle. “Just today there were several announcements about how they’re going to have to provide more transparency.”
Fraser offers similar advice, pointing out that keeping coins in an exchange is almost always a bad idea, no matter what’s going on with the broader market.
“FDX is not the first exchange to fail,” says Fraser. “The whole point of crypto is that you don’t have to trust other people anymore. Crypto was designed to save us from this exact problem—these opaque systems where you don’t know what is being done with your money.”
2. Custody your own assets
Related to the points just made, rather than keeping coins on exchanges or with brokerages, it’s far safer to custody your own assets. This means keeping them in a physical hardware wallet similar to a USB drive or alternatively, in an online software wallet. In both cases, you are the one who maintains control over the coins and access to them is protected through private key cryptography.
“Private key cryptography is the same technology that allows us to visit a website and enter our credit card information online safely,” explains Fraser. “It’s the same technology as that. These keys are what secure your assets, your digital assets.”
When you opt for a hardware wallet, such as a Ledger device, only when you are moving crypto currency around do you put your coins on the internet. The rest of the time, they can be kept in your hardware wallet in a safe, or safety deposit box, says Eberle.
3. Invest in professionally managed accounts
For high net worth crypto investors, yet another measure of safety may be achieved by investing through professionally-managed accounts. This is what Eberle’s own firm, Castle Funds, does. He specializes in working with accredited, high-net-worth investors and when handling crypto investments the firm uses offline custody tools for client’s assets.
“The vast majority of the time, our tokens are in custody offline, so it does away with the risk, such as an exchange risk,” says Eberle. “The only reason to leave tokens on an exchange is laziness, or lack of understanding in terms of how to put crypto in your wallet.”
If you are new to crypto investing, it’s important to have someone who is experienced, guide you through the process of putting crypto in your own wallet.
Bottom line, says Fraser, is that crypto investing as a whole remains safe. But exchanges and brokerages continue to lack transparency.
“Don’t confuse what’s happening on these exchanges with crypto itself,” says Fraser. “Absolutely do not leave money on exchanges. Pull it off. But that’s true all the time. For people who are too scared to handle self custody, consider regulated platforms like Coinbase, which is transparent and publishes its reserves. Using platforms like Coinbase, people can see there’s no funny business and that their money is safe.”
EDITORIAL DISCLOSURE: The advice, opinions, or rankings contained in this article are solely those of the Fortune Recommends™ editorial team. This content has not been reviewed or endorsed by any of our affiliate partners or other third parties.