• 前美国财政部长和前哈佛大学(Harvard)校长拉里·萨默斯表示:“现在哈佛大学大多数学生的分数全都是A,这令我感到困扰。”
常春藤盟校的教育以其极为严格的要求而闻名。但对于被哈佛录取的学生来说,在学业上的成功比你想象的更为普遍。
根据《哈佛校报》(Harvard Crimson)的报道,在哈佛大学2024届毕业生中,约有五分之一的学生报告称,他们的平均学分绩点(GPA)几乎完美,接近4.0。近80%的学生平均GPA为3.7或更高——相当于A-或更高。
如此高的分数引起了教师们对分数膨胀的担忧,因为相对而言,学业上的成功并不突出。
哈佛大学教授兼名誉校长拉里·萨默斯对《财富》表示,高等教育机构的优先事项不正确。
他表示:“我认为这些机构应该进行反思,他们应该知道以追求真理为己任的重要性,而不仅仅是关注社会正义;他们应该追求机会,而不是追求身份政治;他们应该崇尚卓越,而不是一味地庆祝相互自尊。”
“例如,现在哈佛大学大多数学生的分数全都是A,这令我感到困扰。我认为在一个竞争更加激烈、卓越变得更加重要的时代,这并没有向我们的学生传递正确的信息。”
分数膨胀问题
去年的一份报告显示,2020-2021学年,哈佛大学得到A段成绩的学生比例,比十年前上升了近20%,这引发了新的讨论。
然而,分数膨胀在高等教育中并不是一个新问题。多年来,公立和私立机构学生的平均GPA一直在缓慢上升。例如,在耶鲁大学(Yale),学生的平均成绩经过疫情期间大幅上升之后持续升高,这引发了人们对于分数膨胀的担忧。2010-2011学年,所有年级67%的学生成绩为A或A-。到2021-2022学年,这一比例上升到82%。
几十年来,萨默斯一直在表达他对这个问题的担忧,部分原因是他担心学生在就业市场上处于不利地位。
他在2002年告诉学生:“我们必须注意不能让哈佛大学的学生处于不利地位。我们必须确保在学校里表现优异的学生,在雇主眼中能够得到同样的认可。”
分数膨胀影响的不仅仅是成绩单上的一个数字。学术荣誉和其他荣誉通常以学生的GPA为依据,这些荣誉在学生争取第一次实习机会或第一份工作时都可能至关重要。
无法让自己脱颖而出,可能对Z世代造成双重打击,因为他们比以往任何时候都更难找到入门级工作。根据Handshake的数据,超过一半的2025届毕业生对即将开始的职业生涯感到悲观。
但一旦应届毕业生找到工作,一些老板就会发现他们并不像宣传的那样出色。据报道,六成雇主解雇了Z世代员工,原因是他们缺乏动力、组织能力和专业精神。
哈佛的问题
除了成绩问题,哈佛大学因其对校园反犹太主义运动的处理而登上了全美媒体的头条,这最终导致了哈佛大学校长克劳迪亚·盖伊的辞职。
萨默斯去年在X上发帖称,他“对哈佛理事会和哈佛领导层是否有决心和能力让这里继续成为犹太人和以色列人可以繁荣发展的地方,已经失去了信心”。
他对《财富》杂志表示,在全美各地的校园里,对反犹太主义的处理方式突显了高等教育机构并不总是对所有观点持开放态度,包括更保守的观点。
哈佛目前还面临着两个倡导团体的诉讼,他们称2023年春季和秋季的事件造成了一个敌对的教育环境。
尽管经历了动荡不安的一年,但哈佛在2024财年获得了其史上第二高的捐款,现用捐款总额超过5.25亿美元。(财富中文网)
译者:刘进龙
审校:汪皓
• 前美国财政部长和前哈佛大学(Harvard)校长拉里·萨默斯表示:“现在哈佛大学大多数学生的分数全都是A,这令我感到困扰。”
常春藤盟校的教育以其极为严格的要求而闻名。但对于被哈佛录取的学生来说,在学业上的成功比你想象的更为普遍。
根据《哈佛校报》(Harvard Crimson)的报道,在哈佛大学2024届毕业生中,约有五分之一的学生报告称,他们的平均学分绩点(GPA)几乎完美,接近4.0。近80%的学生平均GPA为3.7或更高——相当于A-或更高。
如此高的分数引起了教师们对分数膨胀的担忧,因为相对而言,学业上的成功并不突出。
哈佛大学教授兼名誉校长拉里·萨默斯对《财富》表示,高等教育机构的优先事项不正确。
他表示:“我认为这些机构应该进行反思,他们应该知道以追求真理为己任的重要性,而不仅仅是关注社会正义;他们应该追求机会,而不是追求身份政治;他们应该崇尚卓越,而不是一味地庆祝相互自尊。”
“例如,现在哈佛大学大多数学生的分数全都是A,这令我感到困扰。我认为在一个竞争更加激烈、卓越变得更加重要的时代,这并没有向我们的学生传递正确的信息。”
分数膨胀问题
去年的一份报告显示,2020-2021学年,哈佛大学得到A段成绩的学生比例,比十年前上升了近20%,这引发了新的讨论。
然而,分数膨胀在高等教育中并不是一个新问题。多年来,公立和私立机构学生的平均GPA一直在缓慢上升。例如,在耶鲁大学(Yale),学生的平均成绩经过疫情期间大幅上升之后持续升高,这引发了人们对于分数膨胀的担忧。2010-2011学年,所有年级67%的学生成绩为A或A-。到2021-2022学年,这一比例上升到82%。
几十年来,萨默斯一直在表达他对这个问题的担忧,部分原因是他担心学生在就业市场上处于不利地位。
他在2002年告诉学生:“我们必须注意不能让哈佛大学的学生处于不利地位。我们必须确保在学校里表现优异的学生,在雇主眼中能够得到同样的认可。”
分数膨胀影响的不仅仅是成绩单上的一个数字。学术荣誉和其他荣誉通常以学生的GPA为依据,这些荣誉在学生争取第一次实习机会或第一份工作时都可能至关重要。
无法让自己脱颖而出,可能对Z世代造成双重打击,因为他们比以往任何时候都更难找到入门级工作。根据Handshake的数据,超过一半的2025届毕业生对即将开始的职业生涯感到悲观。
但一旦应届毕业生找到工作,一些老板就会发现他们并不像宣传的那样出色。据报道,六成雇主解雇了Z世代员工,原因是他们缺乏动力、组织能力和专业精神。
哈佛的问题
除了成绩问题,哈佛大学因其对校园反犹太主义运动的处理而登上了全美媒体的头条,这最终导致了哈佛大学校长克劳迪亚·盖伊的辞职。
萨默斯去年在X上发帖称,他“对哈佛理事会和哈佛领导层是否有决心和能力让这里继续成为犹太人和以色列人可以繁荣发展的地方,已经失去了信心”。
他对《财富》杂志表示,在全美各地的校园里,对反犹太主义的处理方式突显了高等教育机构并不总是对所有观点持开放态度,包括更保守的观点。
哈佛目前还面临着两个倡导团体的诉讼,他们称2023年春季和秋季的事件造成了一个敌对的教育环境。
尽管经历了动荡不安的一年,但哈佛在2024财年获得了其史上第二高的捐款,现用捐款总额超过5.25亿美元。(财富中文网)
译者:刘进龙
审校:汪皓
• Larry Summers, the former United States Secretary of the Treasury and Harvard president, says: “I’ve been very troubled that at Harvard now the most common grade is a straight A.”
Getting an Ivy League education is known for being extremely rigorous. But for Harvard students who get admitted, classroom success is more widespread than you might think.
About one in five students from Harvard’s graduating class of 2024 reported having a nearly perfect GPA, rounding to 4.0, according to the Harvard Crimson. Nearly 80% had an average GPA of 3.7 or greater—or roughly an A– or higher.
These high grades have caused concern among the faculty about grade inflation since relative course success is less distinct.
Larry Summers, Harvard professor and president emeritus, tells Fortune that higher education institutions do not have their priorities straight.
“I think that there is a need for these institutions to reflect on the importance of pursuing truth as their mission, rather than social justice, pursuing opportunity rather than pursuing identity politics, and venerating excellence rather than simply celebrating mutual self-esteem,” he says.
“For example, I’ve been very troubled that at Harvard now the most common grade is a straight A. I think a time when we have a more competitive world and when excellence is ever more important, I don’t think that’s sending the right type of signal to our students.”
The issue with grade inflation
New conversations at Harvard were sparked last year when a report revealed that A-range grades were up nearly 20% for students in the 2020–21 academic year, as compared to the decade prior.
However, grade inflation is not a new concern in higher education. The average GPAs of students at both public and private institutions have been slowly rising for years, and at Yale, for example, recent concerns about grade inflation arose after averages continued to rise after a stark spike during the pandemic. Sixty-seven percent of all grades were either an A or A– in the 2010–11 academic year. By 2021–22, that number had risen to 82%.
Summers has been voicing his concerns about the issue for decades, in part due to worries about students being disadvantaged in the job market.
“We’ve got to be sensitive not to put Harvard students at a disadvantage,” he told students in 2002. “We’ve got to make sure a student who performs well is seen that way by employers.”
Grade inflation can have a wider impact than just a number on a transcript. Academic honors and other distinctions are often based on a student’s GPA—all of which may matter when trying to secure a first internship or job.
Not being able to distinguish themselves can be a double whammy for Gen Zers, who are struggling more than ever to secure entry-level jobs—with over half of the class of 2025 reported feeling pessimistic about soon starting their careers, according to Handshake.
But once recent graduates land a job, some bosses are finding them to not be as great as advertised. Six in 10 employers have reportedly fired Gen Z workers, citing a lack of motivation, organization, and professionalism.
Trouble at Harvard
Beyond grades, Harvard had made national headlines for its handling of anti-Semitism on campus—something that eventually led to the resignation of Harvard’s president, Claudine Gay.
Summers posted on X last year that he had “lost confidence in the determination and ability of the Harvard Corporation and Harvard leadership to maintain Harvard as a place where Jews and Israelis can flourish.”
At campuses across the country, he tells Fortune, the handling of anti-Semitism has highlighted how institutions of higher education have not always been open to all viewpoints, including more conservative perspectives.
Harvard is also currently facing a lawsuit by two advocacy groups over what they describe as a hostile educational environment from incidents in the spring and fall of 2023.
Despite a rocky year, Harvard saw its second-highest donation haul in its history, with more than $525 million in current-use donations in fiscal year 2024.