首页 500强 活动 榜单 商业 科技 领导力 专题 品牌中心
杂志订阅

网民大量逃离X,美国迎来社交媒体碎片化时代

KALI HAYS
2024-11-19

很多人抛弃了X,转投其他平台,这很可能会彻底改变社交媒体行业的格局。

文本设置
小号
默认
大号
Plus(0条)

马斯克参加特朗普的竞选活动。图片来源:JIM WATSON/AFP VIA GETTY IMAGES

就在近日特朗普赢得美国大选后不久,大量网民纷纷表示,他们以后再不准备使用社交平台X了。理由是该平台的老板马斯克支持特朗普,另外X上的恶毒言论也有增加之势。

乔迪・阿弗里根是一位媒体制作人,也是一个网红主播,他在X上拥有5万粉丝。最近,他在另一个社交平台Threads表示,他以后再也不会使用X了,因为“马斯克成了我们社会和政治里的一股极具破坏性的力量,我不想跟他有任何关联”。在X上拥有百万粉丝的MSNBC女主播妮科尔・华莱士也在电视节目中表示,“为了保护自我,我今天已经把推特删了。”网红蒂・瓦特里斯也在Threads上表示,她已经在X上活跃了15年了,她在X上发表了很多关于流行文化和真人秀的搞笑见解,现在“看到它变成如今这副地狱般的模样,真是令人痛心疾首”。就连在X上非常活跃的大作史蒂芬·金也转投了Threads,他对自己在X上的700万粉丝说:“我曾试图留下来,但是这里的氛围已经变得非常有毒。”

这么多人抛弃了X,转投其他平台,这很可能会彻底改变社交媒体行业的格局。在之前的十多年里,具有这么强大的新闻传播、意见分享和造梗能力的社交平台屈指可数。不过现在,美国又出现了几个千万用户级别的新平台,比如Meta旗下的Threads,以及Bluesky。

自从马斯克2022年收购X以来,它的日活跃用户数量就一直在持续下降。去年它大约拥有2.5亿日活跃用户。马斯克曾宣称,2024年这个数字将增长到10亿。不过据市场情报公司Sensor Tower指出,在11月初的美国大选日当天,X上只有1.62亿活跃用户,而且这还是一年来数据最高的一天。就在次日,这个数字又下降了500万,活跃用户数跌到了1.57亿。

Sensor Tower公司表示,自从X被马斯克收购以来,它平均每月都会流失掉14%的用户。该公司的研究负责人西玛·沙阿告诉《财富》,尽管大选日当天,X的活跃用户数略有增加,但仍止不住持续下滑的势头。

马斯克在入主X后不久,便对这个社交平台进行了重大改革,以推进他心中的“言论自由”。他把原推特的几百名内容审核员裁得只剩下了几名合同工,一些宣传“白人至上论”等极端言论的账号又开始得以发声。另外,X平台只对付费账号提供验证,这实际上是把平台搞成了一个大号的收费网游。马斯克还对平台算法进行了调整,使平台更容易推送煽动性帖子和保守派的热点话题,他自己也乐此不疲地参与言论纷争,包括经常向他的2亿粉丝传播政治和种族方面的阴谋论。

在美国大选后期,马斯克甚至亲自下场为特朗普站台,并且大肆“撒币”助选,利用X平台疯狂摇唇鼓舌,以确保特朗普二次当政。后来他一直在佛罗里达州,就近给特朗普助选。当然,他本人也因从龙之功而获得了丰厚回报。他已经被特朗普提名为一个叫“政府效率部”的新部门的负责人。这个部门的英文名“DOGE”恰好跟马斯克亲自带货的数字货币“狗狗币”同名。谁敢说这是巧合?

在许多用户来说,一个平台不管曾经承载着怎样的记忆,但它现在沦落成这副样子,就已经是“人间不值得”了。所以就在特朗普当选后,又有一大批网民宣称要退出X——而且这次是永远退出。就算他们决定保留自己的X账号,也发誓不会在上面发布任何内容了。

哈佛大学伯克曼克莱因中心的应用社交媒体实验室高级主任乔纳森・贝拉克对《财富》表示:“一段时间以来,网民一直在逐渐远离X平台。当然,当下有很多人公然宣称要退出X,但其实上,这种趋势已经开始好几个月了。我想弄清楚的是,大家这么做究竟是因为理念问题,还是因为平台的体验变糟了。”

在X走向式微的同时,其他一些形式的网络媒体形式的影响力则在持续上升,比如直播、长视频、群聊和视频网站评论区等等。与此同时,其他几个新平台的影响力也在逐步上升。比如很多公众人物和记者,他们历来都是X上的中流砥柱,但是现在他们会在Threads、Bluesky和X这几个平台上发布完全一样的内容,在哪个平台火了,他们就会押注哪个平台。

许多年来,任何竞争对手几乎都无法捍动推特的地位,因为它的网络效应非常强大,它的用户越多,它就变得越有用,因此也就吸引了更多的人想要加入。这种良性循环维持了很长时间,使得任何初创公司,哪怕是像Meta这样的巨头,都不敢在这个赛道上直接与其争锋。十年前,Meta的CEO马克・扎克伯格曾打趣道,推特“就是一辆开进金矿的小丑车”。当马斯克开始对推特进行大刀阔斧的改革时,扎克伯格安排了 15名工程师,开始着手打造一个山寨版的推特,也就是现在的Threads。

不管人们离开X的原因是什么,他们最有可能去的平台只有两个,一个是Threads,另一个就是由推特前CEO杰克·多尔西创办的Bluesky。这两个平台都是去年上线的,目前在苹果应用商店美国区免费应用下载量排行榜上分列第一和第二,而且竞争非常激烈。Meta旗下的WhatsApp和TikTok也在免费应用下载榜前10名中。但是X则排在了第29位,已经落后于Meta旗下的脸书和Instagram。

目前,没有一家第三方研究服务能说清一个用户什么时候会在手机上删除某个APP。不过SimilarWeb公司发现,就在11月初美国大选日的第二天,就有至少11.5万名用户通过网络注销了他们的X账号。同日,谷歌搜索中“删除X”一词的热度上升了150%,而且此后每天都以两位数的百分比持续增长。就连《卫报》本周也表示,由于X上“令人不安的推广内容增多”,《卫报》将放弃它在X上的全部80个官方账号,这些账号总共拥有2700万粉丝。

就在上周,很多X上的头部网红都表示,他们流失了大量粉丝,少则几十,多则成百上千。比如在X上拥有15万粉丝的布伦特・特罗德里安在Threads上表示,自美国大选以来,他已经流失了大约1000名X粉丝。X平台上的另一位百万级网红、善于撰写政治和时事通讯的亚伦・鲁帕表示,上周大概有1万个粉丝取关了他。他表示:“虽然我也发过一两条不怎么样的推文,但我觉得这和我发的内容没什么关系。”

尽管网上有人猜测,这种粉丝数量的突然下降,可能与平台处置“僵尸粉”、“机器人账号”有关,但目前并没有明确的证据来支持这一观点。

无论如何,X的粉丝流失情况,与竞争平台上的活跃度增长是同时发生的。据Sensor Tower公司称,上个月Threads平台的新用户同比增长了394%。Meta公司也在10月份表示,该平台的月活跃用户已达到2.75亿。同时负责Instagram和Threads两大平台的亚当・莫塞里上周四表示,11月份以来,Threads又新增了1500万用户,并且“连续三个月每天都有超过100万的新用户注册”。

相比之下,虽然Bluesky的用户数量要少得多,但在上周,随着离开X的人越来越多,很多人都在讨论弃用X之后去哪里,Bluesky和Threads都成了人们的热门选项。自大选日以来,它已经新增了将近100万用户,总用户数达到了近1500万。

另外根据Sensor Tower公司的数据,在过去一年里,TikTok、脸书、Instagram和Snapchat的月活跃用户也在持续增加,新增比例从3%到10%不等。

尽管网民在纷纷逃离X,而且它的推荐算法也明显倾向右翼政客和马斯克本人,但是有人离开的同时,也会有人进来。美国讨厌特朗普的人不少,连带着讨厌马斯克的人也大有人在,但是也有人就吃特朗普和马斯克这一套。

“尽管过去几年,X在美国的活跃用户数量总体上持续大幅下降,但它在新用户方面也出现了相当大的增长。”Sensor Tower公司负责人对《财富》表示。

Sensor Tower公司指出,今年10月,X的移动端用户注册量上涨了17%,这也是自马斯克接手以来,为数不多的新用户显著增长的月份之一。

虽然这点增长还不足以抵消自马斯克收购以来平台持续流失的用户数量,但用户在平台间的大幅迁移,已成为网络碎片化新时代的一个重要特征。哈佛大学的贝拉克表示,这种碎片化也将带走推特的一部分媒体和文化影响力,以后或许再也不会有一个平台或者一种媒体类型能再次拥有那样的影响力了。

“推特一直拥有一种与其用户数量不成比例的影响力,就像一个公共广场,但社交媒体未必只能以这样的一种方式运作。现在很多人离开了X,社交媒体格局呈现碎片化,人们分散聚拢在其他平台上。这种现象再次强调了一个事实,那就是以后可能不会再有一个权威性的平台了,而这或许是件好事。”(财富中文网)

译者:朴成奎

就在近日特朗普赢得美国大选后不久,大量网民纷纷表示,他们以后再不准备使用社交平台X了。理由是该平台的老板马斯克支持特朗普,另外X上的恶毒言论也有增加之势。

乔迪・阿弗里根是一位媒体制作人,也是一个网红主播,他在X上拥有5万粉丝。最近,他在另一个社交平台Threads表示,他以后再也不会使用X了,因为“马斯克成了我们社会和政治里的一股极具破坏性的力量,我不想跟他有任何关联”。在X上拥有百万粉丝的MSNBC女主播妮科尔・华莱士也在电视节目中表示,“为了保护自我,我今天已经把推特删了。”网红蒂・瓦特里斯也在Threads上表示,她已经在X上活跃了15年了,她在X上发表了很多关于流行文化和真人秀的搞笑见解,现在“看到它变成如今这副地狱般的模样,真是令人痛心疾首”。就连在X上非常活跃的大作史蒂芬·金也转投了Threads,他对自己在X上的700万粉丝说:“我曾试图留下来,但是这里的氛围已经变得非常有毒。”

这么多人抛弃了X,转投其他平台,这很可能会彻底改变社交媒体行业的格局。在之前的十多年里,具有这么强大的新闻传播、意见分享和造梗能力的社交平台屈指可数。不过现在,美国又出现了几个千万用户级别的新平台,比如Meta旗下的Threads,以及Bluesky。

自从马斯克2022年收购X以来,它的日活跃用户数量就一直在持续下降。去年它大约拥有2.5亿日活跃用户。马斯克曾宣称,2024年这个数字将增长到10亿。不过据市场情报公司Sensor Tower指出,在11月初的美国大选日当天,X上只有1.62亿活跃用户,而且这还是一年来数据最高的一天。就在次日,这个数字又下降了500万,活跃用户数跌到了1.57亿。

Sensor Tower公司表示,自从X被马斯克收购以来,它平均每月都会流失掉14%的用户。该公司的研究负责人西玛·沙阿告诉《财富》,尽管大选日当天,X的活跃用户数略有增加,但仍止不住持续下滑的势头。

马斯克在入主X后不久,便对这个社交平台进行了重大改革,以推进他心中的“言论自由”。他把原推特的几百名内容审核员裁得只剩下了几名合同工,一些宣传“白人至上论”等极端言论的账号又开始得以发声。另外,X平台只对付费账号提供验证,这实际上是把平台搞成了一个大号的收费网游。马斯克还对平台算法进行了调整,使平台更容易推送煽动性帖子和保守派的热点话题,他自己也乐此不疲地参与言论纷争,包括经常向他的2亿粉丝传播政治和种族方面的阴谋论。

在美国大选后期,马斯克甚至亲自下场为特朗普站台,并且大肆“撒币”助选,利用X平台疯狂摇唇鼓舌,以确保特朗普二次当政。后来他一直在佛罗里达州,就近给特朗普助选。当然,他本人也因从龙之功而获得了丰厚回报。他已经被特朗普提名为一个叫“政府效率部”的新部门的负责人。这个部门的英文名“DOGE”恰好跟马斯克亲自带货的数字货币“狗狗币”同名。谁敢说这是巧合?

在许多用户来说,一个平台不管曾经承载着怎样的记忆,但它现在沦落成这副样子,就已经是“人间不值得”了。所以就在特朗普当选后,又有一大批网民宣称要退出X——而且这次是永远退出。就算他们决定保留自己的X账号,也发誓不会在上面发布任何内容了。

哈佛大学伯克曼克莱因中心的应用社交媒体实验室高级主任乔纳森・贝拉克对《财富》表示:“一段时间以来,网民一直在逐渐远离X平台。当然,当下有很多人公然宣称要退出X,但其实上,这种趋势已经开始好几个月了。我想弄清楚的是,大家这么做究竟是因为理念问题,还是因为平台的体验变糟了。”

在X走向式微的同时,其他一些形式的网络媒体形式的影响力则在持续上升,比如直播、长视频、群聊和视频网站评论区等等。与此同时,其他几个新平台的影响力也在逐步上升。比如很多公众人物和记者,他们历来都是X上的中流砥柱,但是现在他们会在Threads、Bluesky和X这几个平台上发布完全一样的内容,在哪个平台火了,他们就会押注哪个平台。

许多年来,任何竞争对手几乎都无法捍动推特的地位,因为它的网络效应非常强大,它的用户越多,它就变得越有用,因此也就吸引了更多的人想要加入。这种良性循环维持了很长时间,使得任何初创公司,哪怕是像Meta这样的巨头,都不敢在这个赛道上直接与其争锋。十年前,Meta的CEO马克・扎克伯格曾打趣道,推特“就是一辆开进金矿的小丑车”。当马斯克开始对推特进行大刀阔斧的改革时,扎克伯格安排了 15名工程师,开始着手打造一个山寨版的推特,也就是现在的Threads。

不管人们离开X的原因是什么,他们最有可能去的平台只有两个,一个是Threads,另一个就是由推特前CEO杰克·多尔西创办的Bluesky。这两个平台都是去年上线的,目前在苹果应用商店美国区免费应用下载量排行榜上分列第一和第二,而且竞争非常激烈。Meta旗下的WhatsApp和TikTok也在免费应用下载榜前10名中。但是X则排在了第29位,已经落后于Meta旗下的脸书和Instagram。

目前,没有一家第三方研究服务能说清一个用户什么时候会在手机上删除某个APP。不过SimilarWeb公司发现,就在11月初美国大选日的第二天,就有至少11.5万名用户通过网络注销了他们的X账号。同日,谷歌搜索中“删除X”一词的热度上升了150%,而且此后每天都以两位数的百分比持续增长。就连《卫报》本周也表示,由于X上“令人不安的推广内容增多”,《卫报》将放弃它在X上的全部80个官方账号,这些账号总共拥有2700万粉丝。

就在上周,很多X上的头部网红都表示,他们流失了大量粉丝,少则几十,多则成百上千。比如在X上拥有15万粉丝的布伦特・特罗德里安在Threads上表示,自美国大选以来,他已经流失了大约1000名X粉丝。X平台上的另一位百万级网红、善于撰写政治和时事通讯的亚伦・鲁帕表示,上周大概有1万个粉丝取关了他。他表示:“虽然我也发过一两条不怎么样的推文,但我觉得这和我发的内容没什么关系。”

尽管网上有人猜测,这种粉丝数量的突然下降,可能与平台处置“僵尸粉”、“机器人账号”有关,但目前并没有明确的证据来支持这一观点。

无论如何,X的粉丝流失情况,与竞争平台上的活跃度增长是同时发生的。据Sensor Tower公司称,上个月Threads平台的新用户同比增长了394%。Meta公司也在10月份表示,该平台的月活跃用户已达到2.75亿。同时负责Instagram和Threads两大平台的亚当・莫塞里上周四表示,11月份以来,Threads又新增了1500万用户,并且“连续三个月每天都有超过100万的新用户注册”。

相比之下,虽然Bluesky的用户数量要少得多,但在上周,随着离开X的人越来越多,很多人都在讨论弃用X之后去哪里,Bluesky和Threads都成了人们的热门选项。自大选日以来,它已经新增了将近100万用户,总用户数达到了近1500万。

另外根据Sensor Tower公司的数据,在过去一年里,TikTok、脸书、Instagram和Snapchat的月活跃用户也在持续增加,新增比例从3%到10%不等。

尽管网民在纷纷逃离X,而且它的推荐算法也明显倾向右翼政客和马斯克本人,但是有人离开的同时,也会有人进来。美国讨厌特朗普的人不少,连带着讨厌马斯克的人也大有人在,但是也有人就吃特朗普和马斯克这一套。

“尽管过去几年,X在美国的活跃用户数量总体上持续大幅下降,但它在新用户方面也出现了相当大的增长。”Sensor Tower公司负责人对《财富》表示。

Sensor Tower公司指出,今年10月,X的移动端用户注册量上涨了17%,这也是自马斯克接手以来,为数不多的新用户显著增长的月份之一。

虽然这点增长还不足以抵消自马斯克收购以来平台持续流失的用户数量,但用户在平台间的大幅迁移,已成为网络碎片化新时代的一个重要特征。哈佛大学的贝拉克表示,这种碎片化也将带走推特的一部分媒体和文化影响力,以后或许再也不会有一个平台或者一种媒体类型能再次拥有那样的影响力了。

“推特一直拥有一种与其用户数量不成比例的影响力,就像一个公共广场,但社交媒体未必只能以这样的一种方式运作。现在很多人离开了X,社交媒体格局呈现碎片化,人们分散聚拢在其他平台上。这种现象再次强调了一个事实,那就是以后可能不会再有一个权威性的平台了,而这或许是件好事。”(财富中文网)

译者:朴成奎

The deluge of goodbye messages from people leaving X began shortly after Donald Trump’s election victory last week. In explaining their decision, many in the exodus cited the same thing: The huge support Elon Musk, the social media service’s owner, gave the Republican candidate during the campaign and the increasing nastiness on his site.

Jody Avrigan, a podcast host and media producer with 50,000 followers on X, said on rival social media service Threads, that he was done using X, because “Elon Musk is a pretty destructive force in our society and politics, I want no part of him.” Nicole Wallace, an anchor on MSNBC with over 1 million followers on X, said on live TV that she’d “deleted Twitter today as an act of self preservation.” Tee Wattress said on Threads she’d been on X for 15 years sharing comedic takes on pop culture and reality TV, but “to see it turn into the hell scape that it is today has been devastating.” Even the author and very active X user Stephen King joined Threads, telling his 7 million X followers that he was leaving the platform. “Tried to stay, but the atmosphere has just become too toxic.”

The large number of people swearing off X for other services may spell the end to social media as we know it. Instead of just of a tiny number of extremely popular sites for posting news, opinions, and memes, as has been the case for more than a decade, a number of new options are gaining millions of users, such Threads, owned by Facebook parent Meta, and Bluesky.

Daily users of X, previously known as Twitter, have declined consistently since Musk acquired it in 2022. Last year, it had roughly 250 million daily active users and Musk claimed that the total would grow to 1 billion in 2024. On election day last week, X had only 162 million daily users—and even that was a yearly high, according to Sensor Tower, a market intelligence firm that tracks the platform. A day later, that number had already dropped by 5 million, to 157 million daily users.

Under Musk’s ownership, X has lost an average of 14% of its users monthly, according to Sensor Tower. Despite the slight boost in daily users on the day of the election, an “elongated slide in active users” has continued, Sensor Tower’s research lead Seema Shah told Fortune.

Shortly after taking over X, Musk made major changes to the platform to advance what he described as “free speech,” whittling down the hundreds of people that once worked on content moderation for Twitter to just a handful of contract employees, reinstating openly white supremacist or otherwise vitriolic personalities, and boosting only accounts that paid to be verified, effectively gamifying the entire platform. He also tilted the algorithm to favor inflammatory posts and conservative flash points, gleefully joining the fray himself, often passing along political and racial conspiracy theories to his 200 million followers.

Late in the recent presidential campaign, Musk overtly joined forces with Trump by campaigning for him and donating heavily to ensure a Trump victory, using X as a tool to that end. He has since been by Trump’s side in Florida and has been rewarded by the President-elect as the co-head of the proposed Department of Government Efficiency, which shares an acronym with a cryptocurrency Musk often promotes.

For many users, such a platform, whatever it may have once been, is no longer fun or useful. And it’s set off the latest chorus of people proclaiming their exit from X—for good this time, even if many have decided to keep their accounts live, but vow not to post anything more on them.

“There has been a steady drift away from X for a while,” Jonathan Bellack, senior director of Harvard University’s Applied Social Media Lab that’s part of the Berkman Klein Center, told Fortune. “And yes, we’re seeing more people doing it more loudly at the moment, but people have been leaving for months and months. Now, I wonder if people are choosing to leave because of their beliefs, or because the experience on the platform has gotten worse.”

This X diaspora has coincided with the rising influence of other forms of media, like podcasts, long-form video, group chats, and comments sections on YouTube and Discord, for instance. It’s also come amid the increasing adoption of newly-founded social media platforms. Today, many public personalities and journalists—long the backbone of Twitter and X—post the same thing across Threads, Bluesky, and X, hedging their bets on what may go viral where.

For years, Twitter enjoyed near immunity from new rivals because its network effect was so strong. The more people who used it, the more useful it became and the more others therefore wanted to join. That flywheel spun for a long time, keeping social media startups and even behemoths like Meta, from even attempting to directly compete. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg quipped a decade ago that Twitter was “a clown car that drove into a goldmine.” When Musk started to take the wheels off of Twitter, Zuckerberg put 15 engineers to work building a veritable clone now known as Threads.

Whatever people’s reasons for leaving X, the two most likely places for people to land is either Threads or Bluesky, a startup initiated by former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey. Both platforms debuted last year and are currently jockeying for first and second place in Apple’s App store for most-downloaded free apps in the U.S. TikTok and WhatsApp, also owned by Meta, are in the top 10 as well. Meanwhile, X is in 29th place, behind other social apps like Facebook and Instagram, both owned by Meta.

No third party research service tracks when users delete an app from their phone. But SimilarWeb found that at least 115,000 users deactivated their X accounts via the web the day after the recent election. That same day, Google Search interest in the phrase “Delete X” rose 150% and has continued to grow by double digit percentage points each day since, according to Huge, a design and technology company that conducts custom research. Even news outlet The Guardian said this week it was abandoning all 80 of his official accounts, with a collective 27 million followers, due to the increase in “disturbing content promoted or found on the platform.”

Another data point is anecdotal: Over the past week, many top X users say they’ve lost significant numbers of followers, ranging from dozens to hundreds or even thousands. Brent Troderian, who has over 150,000 followers on X, said on Threads that he’s lost about 1,000 followers since the election. Another well-known figure on X, Aaron Rupar, who writes a newsletter on politics and media, said he hemorrhaged 10,000 of his nearly 1 million followers last week. “While I’m not above a bad tweet or two, I don’t think it’s anything I posted,” he wrote.

Although there has been speculation online that some of these declines could be related to bots or inauthentic accounts suddenly leaving or being deleted from the platform, there is no clear evidence to support the notion.

In any case, such follower losses coincide with growth in activity on rival platforms. New users of Threads in the last month grew 394% year over year, according to Sensor Tower. Meta said in October the service had reached 275 million monthly active users. Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram who also oversees Threads, said Thursday that the platform had added another 15 million users so far in November, and was “going on three months with more than a million sign ups a day.”

While Bluesky has far fewer users, it’s been a trending topic on X and Threads over the last week as people discussed where there were heading while leaving X. Since the election, it has added almost 1 million new users, to a total of nearly 15 million.

TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat have all added users as well each month over the last year, from 3% to 10%, according to Sensor Tower.

Despite all of the apparent momentum away from X, and the manipulation of its content algorithm in favor of right-wing politics and Musk himself, at least some of the people who may be leaving X are being replaced by new users. It’s possible there is a sort of swap going on—use among people fed up with the pro-Trump drift and Musk’s omnipresence is, to some extent, being covered by people who are attracted to exactly that.

“Although X has experienced this elongated decline in overall US active users over the past few years, it has seen a sizable uptick in new users, or those who had previously never registered a session on X,” Shah of Sensor Tower told Fortune.

According to Sensor Tower, new mobile app users for X jumped 17% in October, among the few notable increases it’s seen since Musk’s takeover.

While this isn’t enough to offset X’s sustained loss in users since Musk’s acquisition, the overall migration among social media platforms is part and parcel to a new era of online fragmentation. This online splintering is taking with it some of the cultural and media power that had coalesced around what was Twitter, according to Bellack of Harvard, and it’s likely that no one platform or type of media will take up that position ever again.

“Twitter always had a level of influence that was disproportionate to its number of users – it had a public square feeling, yes, but there’s no reason that’s the only way social media can work,” Bellack said. “People leaving X, the fragmentation and people sorting themselves in other places, it’s just reinforcing the notion that there will no longer be one definitive platform, and that’s probably a good thing.”

财富中文网所刊载内容之知识产权为财富媒体知识产权有限公司及/或相关权利人专属所有或持有。未经许可,禁止进行转载、摘编、复制及建立镜像等任何使用。
0条Plus
精彩评论
评论

撰写或查看更多评论

请打开财富Plus APP

前往打开